Pakistan has a perennial habit of envying India. If we look back,
every accolade the world’s largest democracy earns makes our neighbours
sulk.
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s aggressive diplomacy
resulting in a likelihood that India may enter the Missile Technology
Control Regime (MCTR) and Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) hasn’t gone down
well with Pakistan. Islamabad’s last-moment efforts backed by China to
stall India’s membership only give credence to the hatred Islamabad
harbours for New Delhi.
Whether Pakistan likes it or not, India is
now a global power to reckon with. On the contrary, despite riding
piggyback on China, Pakistan has hardly reaped any benefit. But does the
Pakistani establishment ever ponder over the real reasons behind the
nation losing ground?
The problem comes from within. The Islamic
Republic of Pakistan suffers from too many archaic practices which don’t
stand it in good stead. Any discussion on Pakistan centres around its
‘clandestine’ support to terrorists. Facts and figures substantiate it.
But deep down, extreme conservatism leading to brutality puts the
country in the dock.
Take a note of three latest incidents which
defamed Pakistan. A school-teacher in Murree is killed because of her
refusal to marry a man much elder to her. The Council of Islamic
Ideology (CII) recommends that men can lightly beat their spouses if
they don’t obey their orders. A woman from Lahore
burns her daughter alive for marrying the person she loved.
These
incidents are good enough to show Pakistan in an abysmal light on
various international forums. At a time when India’s presence globally
is being acknowledged, Pakistan is severely afflicted by fundamentalism
that is bereft of any logic.
And it is these obsolete ideas that
are encashed by outfits like Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Mohammad, Taliban,
IS and others to foment trouble on the Pakistani soil. There’s a trend
to raise the name of religion and impose meaningless ideas on people and
it’s all engineered by the Mullahs. But who has the audacity to stop
them? In the process innocent lives are taken.
The problem with
Pakistan is its fragile democracy. Anybody with modern thoughts has to
acquiesce to the whims and fancies of religious elements. Oscar-winning
documentary filmmaker Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy had to face flak back home
for supporting women’s cause through her short documentary
A Girl in the River.
Neither the Nawaz Sharif government nor the army shows any strong urge
to take the bull by its horns. The result is: rampant human-rights
violations.
Compare Pakistan to India and the latter is on a much
better platform because of its civil society. Religious radicalism meets
with vehement protests from intellectuals and students. The Dadri
lynching incurred so much of wrath that awards were returned by
distinguished personalities. The media doesn’t mince words when
deceptive blasphemy is propagated by religious ‘messiahs’. However, it
would be wrong to say there are no human rights violations in India, but
vis-à-vis Pakistan, the incidence is lesser.
On the contrary,
Pakistan continues to be a pawn at the hands of extremists. The
religious minorities in the country live in a fear zone unlike in India.
Indian Muslim women can actually stand up against the triple talaq
system. According to a report by the Amnesty International on Pakistan, “
Religious
minorities, both Muslim and non-Muslim, continued to face laws and
practices that resulted in discrimination and persecution…. Blasphemy
laws remained in force, mostly in Punjab province; they applied to
people of all religions but were disproportionately used against
religious minorities.”
Given this scenario, it’s not
surprising that Pakistan is making more enemies than friends. Iran,
Afghanistan and USA prefer India to Pakistan. And that leaves Pakistan
with only China to bank on. But let’s not forget a strong anti-China
block is on the cards which certainly puts the Chinese government in a
no-win situation. Apprehending isolation China may not hesitate to walk
out on Pakistan. If that is to happen, Pakistan will be in a tight spot
without friends.
Can Islamabad afford it? Instead of taking India
on, Pakistan should now focus on strengthening democratic values and
open the windows for fresh air to enter. In a country where a minister
makes objectionable remarks at a lady lawmaker in the parliament and
still gets away with it, there’s a lot to worry about.
Wake up Pakistan, it’s time!